News / Traffic cops as tax collectors

One fine Sunday morning in May I parked in Main Road Fish Hoek while I dashed into the bank to use the ATM. Five minutes later there was a ticket on my car for parking in a loading zone. The fine was to be R200.

It was obviously a mistake. There was no inconvenience to anybody. There was no danger to vehicle or pedestrian. People have always parked in these loading zones on Sundays and at night and if there was to be some change of policy surely there would be a warning and an explanation. A simple courtesy slip under a windscreen wiper would have done the trick.

That’s just good public relations. That’s how you build and retain good relations with ratepayers.

I dashed off an email off to the municipality, pointing out (rather briskly, I must admit) that the ticket was unreasonable and more likely to generate resentment than achieve any good purpose. I was asked to fax through the parking ticket and this, together with my note, would be used as my representation against the fine.

That done I forgot about the whole matter. I had no doubt that wiser City officials would sort it out, perhaps even have a word with the errant traffic officer about excessive zeal and how counterproductive it could be.

My attitude changed, however, when a “final warning” arrived in the post. Yes, they really wanted their R200. It was confirmation that it was all about money and not road safety or an attempt to protect the rights of delivery services because there are none at 10.30 on a Sunday morning in Fish Hoek or anywhere else.

Now R200 would buy a poor pensioner 30 loaves of plain brown bread, enough to last him for two months. And there are a lot of pensioners in Fish Hoek. All good soft targets!

Frankly, I wondered if it was revenge for a column I wrote on how the City was spending R150 000 on hopelessly overpowered motorbikes for the traffic department when they could buy more suitable machines for half the price.

But no, the manager of Pick n Pay also got a ticket, and I doubt he has given similar offence.

Now I strongly support vigorous road safety enforcement and I have even paid speeding fines (like a sinful 72km/h on New Boyes Drive) without a murmur.

It is now clear to me that we are not dealing with traffic officers. They are tax collectors. Do they get commission like the hated Roman tax collectors of old or do they just have targets to meet? I don’t know, but they are giving road safety campaigns a bad name.

They are undermining the credibility of the City and its law enforcement efforts.

They are destroying good relations between the public and officials.

Is this how the City works for you?

  COMMENTS 
 
delanaux wrote:   
2011-08-24 20:16

Hey Felix. I will answer in the form of your previous comment. I fully agree, the services rendered by traffic departments are not good enough, but it has a lot to do with lack of funding, I honestly would not work for 6 - 7 days a week on what those guys make. I also agree with your statement that no one should be sent to jail without an argument, but the smaller laws that govern road users is clear as daylight and no argument is necessary. There is no way you can explain your way out of being guilty as 99% of the times when it comes to traffic fines it can be proven there and then. No need for witnesses etc to be called. I think we South Africans are still lucky as we do not have the demerit points system in place yet, in the UK they come down on road users much harder than here. I am very glad to hear you vote! LOL I really do understand the argument, i just really hate when people make a noise about something that they know they are guilty off. Apology accepted (battery chicken issue) hehehe, really did not take offence. Oh yes, hehehehe, chickens can vote, did you not see the ANCYL vote Malema back into office? HAHAHA guessing Tyger Burger might delete that comment, but hey, taking a chance that they might not.
Felix wrote:   
2011-08-22 22:20

Hi delanaux. I will elaborate on my argument as you have missed it once again. I say again - The revolt is against battery-chicken mentality - I am saying services rendered by the traffic department are not good enough yet. It must be improved. Yes I am dissatisfied. I agree with you - laws should not discriminate (although in the real world they often do). However no one should be sentenced to jail without an argument (unless you are a battery chicken and just accept your fate to end up being KFC). I did not say I do not vote, I was merely pointing out the lack of service. I am not unthankful for our roads and loading zones and traffic cops and speed cameras and intersections. This does however not mean that they should not improve. I sincerely hope you understand my argument in paragraph one. I apologize for calling you a battery chicken, maybe if I didn’t do it, you would not have assumed me being a Gr1 free range chicken (which of course I take as great compliment) and would not have referred to me as the type that doesn’t vote (by the way - chickens are not allowed to vote anyway).
delanaux wrote:   
2011-08-21 16:43

Dear Felix. Let me understand your argument. Because everyone is not the same, it means that murder for one person is not the same for another? Cause as far as i know, laws do not discriminate, which is what the author and yourselves are saying. The laws should be lenient because you are poor, black, white, rich etc.? The author was met with a response to his ticket, he needs to pay it was the response. In a perfect world one might use your initiative regarding certain issues but the author was not there to argue his point. A traffic officer's work entails he/she to also make sure road users do not break the law, it's not just all about safety but in the end it all boils down to the fact that the author was illegally parked. No need for you to try and explain the scenario. It's very simple for the "battery - chickens": you murder, you go to jail. For you the "free-range-chicken" it's more like: you murder, we warn and send you on your merry way. Because we are all different and clearly the "free-range-chickens" does not have laws to abide to. And when it comes to voting, let me explain it to you in an easy Gr1 way so that you may understand: voting is like buying a packet of wine gums, you don't really eat the green ones, the orange is okay but you love the red and black ones. You will never get everything you want and you need to deal with it. This is still a 3rd world developing country. You honestly do sound like the type that don't vote and still complain about the potholes. Never satisfied.
Felix wrote:   
2011-08-21 15:26

#expletive removed#
Felix wrote:   
2011-08-21 15:25

but with two t's as in b u tt is an expletive? even in the word b u t t o n ?
Felix wrote:   
2011-08-21 15:20

a bit of a sticky button there
Felix wrote:   
2011-08-21 15:19

Dear Werner and delanaux, I believe you miss the point. The revolt is against battery-chicken mentality. Battery-chickens - this is exactly what you are - believe one size fits all, everybody is the same, anything the law says is good and that you should suffer because you are a chicken, but thank goodness there will always be people like you, without the battery chickens there would be no KFC. I'm glad I'm a free range chicken and can think out of the box. The parking ticket may be CORRECTLY issued in a battery chicken world, but in my free range chicken world it is certainly not. If I had taken my time to write a letter with my side of the story, and was met with no response I would be upset too. It would implicate that yes, my thinking is correct (after all no caring letter explaining my error has been received, thus I assume there was no error), I may carry on parking in loading zones, but it is all about the money - please [A] Traffic cop need to give X- amount of people tickets or else he/she is in trouble, or [B] traffic cop need to pay his/her kid's school fees and need the commission. Traffic cops are tax collectors, taxing those earning less even more and allowing the rich to do as they please. Free range chickens need to address this problem because battery chickens can't. It is all about the money to buy KFC and NOBODY cares for your safety. Next time I will vote for NOBODY because she cares about my safety. NOBODY will reply to my letter stating my side of the story and NOBODY will post me a simple courtesy slip under the windscreen. NOBODY works for me.
Felix wrote:   
2011-08-21 15:19

Dear Werner and delanaux, I believe you miss the point. The revolt is against battery-chicken mentality. Battery-chickens - this is exactly what you are - believe one size fits all, everybody is the same, anything the law says is good and that you should suffer because you are a chicken, but thank goodness there will always be people like you, without the battery chickens there would be no KFC. I'm glad I'm a free range chicken and can think out of the box. The parking ticket may be CORRECTLY issued in a battery chicken world, but in my free range chicken world it is certainly not. If I had taken my time to write a letter with my side of the story, and was met with no response I would be upset too. It would implicate that yes, my thinking is correct (after all no caring letter explaining my error has been received, thus I assume there was no error), I may carry on parking in loading zones, but it is all about the money - please [A] Traffic cop need to give X- amount of people tickets or else he/she is in trouble, or [B] traffic cop need to pay his/her kid's school fees and need the commission. Traffic cops are tax collectors, taxing those earning less even more and allowing the rich to do as they please. Free range chickens need to address this problem because battery chickens can't. It is all about the money to buy KFC and NOBODY cares for your safety. Next time I will vote for NOBODY because she cares about my safety. NOBODY will reply to my letter stating my side of the story and NOBODY will post me a simple courtesy slip under the windscreen. NOBODY works for me.
12
WEATHER
Weather for Saturday 2012-05-19
Please select your area for forecast
CPT 11° - 15° icon
PTA 7° - 25° icon
JHB 5° - 22° icon
BLOEM 0° - 17° icon
DBN 14° - 21° icon
PE 7° - 14° icon
Visit WeatherSA.co.za for a more detailed forecast.
 
What's Happening
Search by category
SCHOOLS
Find local schools
Groups / Clubs
Find local Groups / Clubs